Thursday, November 19, 2026 01:01 PM

Rabi, Balen alliance under strain?

By Our Reporter

The growing distance between Rastriya Swatantra Party (RSP) chair Rabi Lamichhane and Prime Minister Balendra Shah points to a problem in the arrangement that brought them together. The two leaders agreed to divide political responsibilities, with Lamichhane leading the party and Shah heading the government for five years. They appear to have left unanswered how the party and the government would consult each other and share responsibility for decisions.

Their political partnership brought together two different strengths. Lamichhane had built a national party, established a parliamentary base and gained support by challenging traditional political forces. Shah, widely known as Balen, had built an independent political profile and an image as an outsider willing to confront established institutions. The RSP offered Shah an organised political platform, while his public standing strengthened the party’s claim to represent an alternative to established parties.

The arrangement gave each leader a distinct role, but the division of responsibilities has become a source of disagreement. Lamichhane appears to expect a say in major government decisions, especially when the RSP is expected to defend them. Shah, according to party leaders, wants greater freedom to run the government without regular intervention from the party leadership.

The dispute over the Prime Minister’s advisers has brought this tension into the open. Lamichhane reportedly recommended nearly three months ago that Shah remove chief political adviser Kumar Ben and political adviser Asim Shah, arguing that they had failed to coordinate effectively between the party and the government. The Prime Minister has yet to act on that recommendation.

For Lamichhane, the issue goes beyond the two appointments. He believes the party has little influence over government decisions but is expected to take responsibility when those decisions attract criticism. Party leaders say he has repeatedly raised concerns with Shah, only to see his suggestions ignored.

Disagreements over government policy have added to his frustration. Lamichhane reportedly opposed the campaign to remove settlements occupied by landless people, the arrest of journalists and the deployment of police personnel at media houses. He also advised against removing then Inspector General of Police Dan Bahadur Karki, but the Prime Minister went ahead.

Another dispute concerns possible impeachment proceedings against judges, including Hari Prasad Phuyal, who has come under scrutiny over alleged links with middleman Inam Sapkota. Lamichhane reportedly supports action against those implicated in the controversy and has instructed the party’s parliamentary wing to take the necessary steps. RSP sources say Shah, who also leads the party’s parliamentary group, has shown little interest in the proposal. No process has begun.

The alleged links between Sapkota and Kumar Ben have added to the pressure for an investigation. Lamichhane’s associates say he wants the matter examined and impeachment proceedings initiated if warranted. They fear the Prime Minister’s reluctance will leave the party’s instructions unimplemented.

Lamichhane has also reportedly warned Shah and his ministers that the repeated arrests of political leaders could harm the international image of the government and the ruling party. His frustration has grown as his advice has failed to bring changes in policy.

He is now said to be telling close associates that the RSP may have to act as an opposition to the government. In his view, opposition parties have been unable to hold the administration accountable because of their limited parliamentary strength and their failure to raise substantive issues. He has instructed party leaders to scrutinise government decisions more closely and speak out when necessary.

This approach could further complicate relations. Shah reportedly suspects that the party may eventually withdraw its support, particularly after senior RSP figures stopped publicly taking ownership of government activities. That suspicion may make him even less willing to follow Lamichhane’s advice.

RSP Chief Whip Prakash Chandra Pariyar rejects the suggestion that the two sides are in serious conflict. He describes the differences as a matter of working styles and interpretations. He says both leaders must honour their understanding: Lamichhane should help the government complete its five-year term, while Shah should support the effective running of the party.

The Prime Minister, however, is said to have shown little interest in filling vacant party office bearer positions or completing the party’s organisational structure. Some RSP leaders say he argues that, just as he does not interfere in party affairs, Lamichhane should leave him free to run the government.

The disagreement is therefore about how much independence each leader can exercise while remaining part of the same political arrangement. One RSP leader says there are no ideological or political differences between Shah’s camp and other factions within the party. The problem, the leader says, is the lack of consultation and the Prime Minister’s reluctance to act on suggestions.

Pariyar has called for high-level talks to resolve the differences. Lamichhane, meanwhile, has urged people not to interpret his criticism of the government as evidence of a split. Speaking in Janakpur during the Chhath festival, he described advice and criticism as signs of internal democracy. He also complained that his comments often generated unnecessary controversy.

Lamichhane has repeatedly said the government will complete its five-year term, referring to the understanding during Deusi-Bhailo celebrations, folk song programmes and interactions with journalists. But that commitment will be difficult to sustain if the party chair continues to feel excluded from decisions while being expected to defend them. The two leaders will have to settle the question of consultation and responsibility if their arrangement is to hold.

Conversation

Login to add a comment