
By Our Reporter
The government’s proposed amendment to the Press Council Act, 1991, has put President Ram Chandra Paudel in an uncomfortable position. He must decide whether to approve an ordinance that the government says will regulate the changing media landscape, but which journalists and press freedom advocates fear could give the state greater control over the media.
The President has yet to receive a briefing on the two ordinances the Cabinet recommended on November 3. The documents reached his office on November 6, but a briefing scheduled for Friday was postponed because his legal adviser, Baburam Kunwar, had not returned from the Tihar holiday. It is now expected on Monday.
The President can issue the ordinance or return the recommendation to the government for reconsideration. His choice will depend on how he reads his constitutional role and what the changes would do. The Federation of Nepali Journalists has urged him not to approve it. Even people and groups who support stronger press freedom protections have asked him to send the proposal back.
Their objection is about who should regulate journalism in a democracy: the media, through independent self-regulation, or the government, through an institution whose leadership and powers can influence.
A central concern is the proposed expansion of the Press Council’s jurisdiction. The amendment extends the journalistic code of conduct to people producing journalistic content through online platforms, social media, mobile applications, and other digital technologies. It also brings content creators, presenters, and influencers who identify themselves as media workers into the regulatory framework.
A wider reach is understandable when the line between traditional journalism and digital content has blurred. False or misleading reports and irresponsible content are real problems. But defining who is a journalist and what counts as journalism needs care.
A broad definition could blur the limits of legitimate expression. The ordinance excludes personal social media posts that are not journalism, yet journalists can still face legal action under Section 47 of the Electronic Transactions Act for views expressed on personal accounts. Professional regulation and individual expression still overlap.
The reported provision requiring disclosure of news sources is more troubling. Protecting confidential sources is a basic condition of investigative journalism. Whistleblowers and people exposing corruption or abuse of authority may refuse to share information if journalists cannot guarantee confidentiality. A provision that weakens that protection could discourage people from approaching the media and make it harder to hold powerful institutions to account for.
The disciplinary powers are also a concern. Repeated violations could lead to recommendations to suspend state facilities provided to journalists and media organisations, and the Council could prescribe the format, size, and deadline for publishing corrections. Correcting inaccurate reporting is a legitimate aim, but powers like these could become tools of pressure if exercised without independence and safeguards.
Former Federation of Nepali Journalists president Dharmendra Jha has argued that the proposal undermines the international principle of media self-regulation. He objects particularly to government influence over appointments, and the Council’s expanded punitive authority.
An independent regulator cannot work well if its leadership is seen as answerable to the government. Its decisions are credible only if journalists and the public believe complaints are handled impartially, including when reporting concerns the government itself.
The proposed single national Press Council raises another question. Provincial press registrar offices already set up under provincial laws could face uncertainty over their authority, employees and future. Letting the national Council establish provincial units does not settle what happens to existing provincial institutions.
The amendment also raises the qualifications for the Council chairperson. Journalism graduates would need a postgraduate degree, 15 years of continuous experience and an outstanding contribution to journalism, while candidates who meet the constitutional qualifications for Supreme Court judgeship could qualify by another route. Whether the criteria are built around professional competence or institutional preferences is a fair question.
The government’s decision to use an ordinance is questionable. It had a near two-thirds majority during a 62-day parliamentary session. Why did it not introduce the amendment in Parliament, where lawmakers could debate it and journalists, legal experts and other stakeholders could present their concerns?
An ordinance is meant for situations that need immediate legal action. It should not replace parliamentary scrutiny, especially legislation touching fundamental freedoms.
Approving the ordinance without addressing these concerns could deepen distrust between the government and the media. Returning it would give the government a chance to consult stakeholders, clarify contentious provisions and bring the amendment through Parliament. Paudel should seek legal advice and examine whether the proposed powers are consistent with constitutional guarantees of freedom of expression and the press. The government can pursue reforms to improve accountability in journalism, but they must protect editorial independence and confidential sources. Returning the ordinance would not reject media regulation, only insist that any reform affecting press freedom get the public and parliamentary scrutiny it deserves.







Login to add a comment