
By Narayan Prasad Mishra
Having reached my mid-eighties, I have witnessed and experienced various political systems in our country, from the Rana regime to the present day. During the Rana regime, I was still a young child. Although I observed that system quite closely, I was too young to experience its pleasures or hardships personally.
In 1951 (2007 B.S.), democracy and the multiparty system emerged together. There were various political parties in the country, and they were constantly engaged in attacking one another. Until the general election of 1959 (2015 B.S.), the King had a practice of appointing one of the leaders of the major political parties as Prime Minister at his discretion.
Those who became Prime Ministers tended to give greater priority to the interests of their own parties, themselves, and their relatives than to the welfare of the country and its people. The remaining parties, which had not enjoyed the benefits of power, raised their voices against this practice. The King would then dismiss the incumbent prime minister and appoint another leader from the party or group raising the strongest opposition. In this manner, the period passed without any substantial work being accomplished for the country.
Demanding the full implementation of the multiparty and parliamentary systems, political parties began pressing for general elections through demonstrations, rallies, and increasingly loud protests. As a result, a general election was held in 1959 (2015 B.S.). The Nepali Congress won an absolute majority, and a government led by its leader, Bishweshwar Prasad Koirala, was formed. Although this government took some initiatives toward national development, the Nepali tendency to prioritize one’s own party, oneself, and one’s relatives remained quite evident. What constituted complete democracy for the Nepali Congress amounted to nothing more than party rule for others. The remaining parties, resentful of this situation, exaggerated minor issues, raised loud protests, and instigated the people. The people became victims of the fierce rivalry among political parties. The country’s situation continued to deteriorate. Concluding that this system would not serve the country’s interests, King Mahendra invoked the relevant constitutional provision, dissolved the government, promulgated the Constitution of Nepal, 1962 (2019 B.S.), and introduced the partyless Panchayat system under the name of Panchayat Democracy.
The Panchayat system was partyless, meaning that political parties were prohibited and people were not divided into competing political parties engaged in endless conflicts. Instead, they were expected to serve the country based on their individual qualifications, competence, knowledge, skills, and abilities. Elections were also held under this system, and an elected legislature continued to function. The government and Council of Ministers were to be formed under the leadership of a prime minister elected by a majority of the legislature. I believe these were also essential elements of democracy.
However, under this system, the King remained the guardian and principal authority, much like a football referee. If political players were found violating established rules and laws, the referee could show a red card and stop the game. In other words, it was a controlled form of democracy.
Under this controlled democracy, unlike the situation prevailing today, the government could not arbitrarily bring the civil service, judiciary, police, army, education, health, industry, commerce, Public Service Commission, and constitutional bodies under the control of the government in power against the constitution. Consequently, professional government institutions could function professionally and independently, without succumbing to pressure or influence from anyone except the palace. We have only now begun to realize the significance of this fact.
Thus, not every public institution became the exclusive property of the political party in power. Except for those political parties that wanted to keep every institution of the country under their control in the name of democracy, with the kitchen, food, plates, bowls, ladles, and everything else in their own hands, ordinary people did not seem to experience much inconvenience under the controlled democracy of that period. Although a limited number of Panchayat leaders enjoyed certain irregular benefits, there was no opportunity for the openly rampant looting that we witness today. The country made progress in many areas of development, and the infrastructure necessary for national development was established. This system continued for nearly 30 years.
Despite whatever democratic qualities the old Panchayat system might have possessed, political parties that refused to recognize controlled democracy as democracy and considered only an unrestricted multiparty system to be genuine democracy continued their struggle against it. Consequently, in 1990 (2047 B.S.), the Panchayat Constitution was abolished, and the 1990 multiparty Constitution was implemented. An unrestricted form of democracy emerged.
However, even this system retained the monarchy, albeit with limited powers. Maoists maintained that the system was not beneficial to the country and that the monarchy itself had to be abolished to accelerate the country’s overall development. The Maoists, together with the seven political parties that supported their position, launched a movement in 2006 (2063 B.S.). As a result, the Constitution of Nepal, 2015 (2072 B.S.), was promulgated. Since then, Nepal has been governed under a republican, multiparty parliamentary system without a King or monarchy.
Today, Nepal has a fully democratic constitutional system. Our Constitution incorporates all the qualities and characteristics that a modern democracy should possess. There does not appear to be anything lacking in our Constitution compared with the constitutions of any other democratic country in the world. Therefore, Nepal undoubtedly has a fully democratic system in its Constitution.
We all know that, whatever name a democratic system may carry, its fundamental responsibilities are to ensure the welfare of the country and its people. These include national development; adequate employment opportunities; access to food, healthcare, education, and shelter; equality and freedom; and an impartial system of justice.
We also know that, in a democracy, all institutions of governance and administration must function independently and impartially within their respective jurisdictions, without pressure or influence from anyone. These include the civil service, police, army, public servants in all sectors, the Public Service Commission, the Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority, the Election Commission, the Judicial Service Commission, the courts, and educational institutions such as universities. All their officials must be able to perform their duties freely, fairly, and without fear or favor. Without these conditions being ensured in practice, democracy exists only in the Constitution, not in reality.
However, since the implementation of the Constitution of Nepal, 1990 (2047 B.S.), although the country has formally had a fully democratic system, democracy has, in practice, become a system serving only the political parties in government, their leaders, and their cadres. What has actually prevailed in the country is undemocratic governance, accompanied by disorder and widespread chaos. This has become a subject of discussion throughout the country.
There is also widespread criticism that, since 1990, none of the political parties that have come to power, nor their governments, have demonstrated democratic political values, conduct, or practices before the people. Instead, they have practiced nothing but undemocratic governance.
For them, democracy has become merely a showpiece, like the visible tusks of an elephant. Their hearts and blood, it is said, have remained devoted not to the country and its people but to their own parties, groups, personal interests, and nepotism. Public grievances that their conduct has made this abundantly clear are not uncommon.
For these political parties and their leaders, democracy does not mean the rule of law. Rather, it appears to mean a system in which the party and its government can do whatever they please, without fear of anyone and without being subject to any control. There is also a widespread perception that this was precisely why they wanted a country without a King and without any effective restraint—in other words, a republic in which they could exercise power without accountability.
Indeed, the public’s grievances are understandable. During this period, all the independent institutions established and functioning under the system of governance to ensure equality, freedom, impartial justice, and clean and honest administration have, in practice, been turned into puppets of whichever political party and its leaders happen to be in power. These institutions include the civil service, police, army, judiciary, educational institutions, and all constitutional bodies.
The numerous cases of policy-level corruption and other forms of corruption that have come to light during this period, the countless cases filed in connection with them, and various incidents currently attracting public attention, including the Inam Sapkota affair involving different forms of corrupt arrangements, have further exposed the undemocratic nature of governance prevailing in the country.
It has therefore become evident that democracy in our country exists only for the political party in power and its leaders and cadres. For the country and its people, what prevails is misgovernance, or undemocratic governance. The majority of the population has been deprived of their rights and basic facilities, forced to endure immense hardship and suffering, and compelled to leave the country in search of work, food, and employment opportunities abroad.
As a consequence of this situation, people began looking for an alternative that could provide good governance, promote development, and put true democracy into practice. In this context, the Rastriya Swatantra Party (RSP) emerged as an alternative and is now in power.
It appears to be making a determined, courageous, and vigorous effort to make the existing democratic system democratic in practice as well by eliminating the undemocratic system of governance prevailing in the country. However, it is certainly too early to evaluate this government’s performance. All patriotic citizens should wish it success in its efforts.
Having experienced both the Panchayat system and the present multiparty system, I have increasingly come to question whether multiparty democracy, as practiced in Nepal, has actually served the national interest better than the partyless Panchayat system. Given the self-centred political leadership, persistent power struggles, corruption, and failure of governance under the multiparty system, I believe this question deserves serious consideration. Although the present atmosphere in the country is such that anyone who speaks out against corruption and misgovernance is labelled a reactionary, I nevertheless feel that failing to speak the truth as seen by one’s conscience is tantamount to being dishonest with oneself.
Nevertheless, unless the people develop a genuine understanding of what true democracy means; unless political parties and their cadres abandon the belief that nepotism and favoritism toward their own people constitute democracy; unless the people raise a strong and persistent voice against such practices; and unless donor countries stop supporting even corrupt governments, our country will remain trapped in sham democracy for generations to come. I sincerely hope that this will not happen. I hope to see genuine democracy established in our country within my lifetime.
About the author: A non-partisan writer and author of several books and numerous articles in Nepali and English, including the book “Nepal: Between Beauty and Struggle”; a retired official of Tribhuvan University; and a senior citizen in his mid-eighties.







Login to add a comment