
By Devendra Gautam
Ahead of our Prime Minister’s upcoming visit to our next-door neighbour, an environment of suspicion has begun enveloping our country. This has nothing to do with climate change and global warming. Suspicion has arisen because the government has not bothered to share the agenda for the visit with the nation, let alone take her into confidence.
This practice – of keeping people in the dark about matters that affect generations to come – has become a ‘time-honoured’ tradition. As they say, the more things change, the more they remain the same, not only in dictatorships but in democratic polities too.
Ominous clouds hover over the Plains, the Himalayas, and the Hills during every such visit. Rumours of another sellout of our rivers and streams spread, along with fears of the beginning—or the abrupt end—of yet another chapter of the unfinished business.
One can, of course, blame conspiracy theorists for doing everything in their power to malign ‘special’, ‘historic’, friendly and ‘people-to-people’ relations heading ‘northwards’ at an alarming rate.
Ties with the South moving further and further northwards hardly inspire confidence in a country seated uncomfortably between two economic and military powers with rising ambitions for global supremacy—and not beyond the reach of the sole superpower in an increasingly interconnected world.
Rather, they stoke up fears of Nepal becoming a hotspot for regional and global conflicts.
But our political and bureaucratic leadership often goes to great lengths to obscure the substance of these high-stakes negotiations behind the opaque curtain of diplomatic protocol, leaving citizens guessing as to what is actually on the table.
Generations of Nepalis continue to live with the consequences of controversial agreements such as the Treaty of Peace and Friendship (1950), the Koshi Agreement (1954), the Gandak Agreement (1959) and the Mahakali Treaty (1996).
Ties between countries are never perfect in high seas where big fish gobble up small fish every now and then. The ‘sovereign equality of nations’ enshrined in the United Nations Charter remains a far cry, and so does the principle of Panchasheel — especially in our case.
How many of our deals and treaties with our neighbour truly align with the Charter?
Tasked with shaping our collective destiny, our functionaries know better, yet their hands remain tied; after all, who can put words into their mouths when institutional candour is treated as a diplomatic liability?
The focus of a youthful and energetic government, formed after elections held in the wake of a youth-led uprising barely a year ago, should have been on making bilateral relations more equal and just by at least revising controversial deals and treaties.
But feelers coming from the government indicate otherwise.
Take, for instance, our Finance Minister’s recent remarks at a media event in the foreign capital where he appeared to disparage Nepali nationalism (or patriotism) by portraying it as essentially against the next-door neighbor, rather than acknowledging its role in steering Nepal through the Cold War and the subsequent period of uneasy peace. Then he went on to declare its end.
How does a scholarly brain work?
This small-time columnist has no idea, but he cannot imagine a small country standing up to a big neighbour in this wild, wild world. A leader declaring the end of a domestic approach in a foreign capital is rather unprecedented.
Scholarly remarks aside, even a mid-sized country with a small population has every right to adopt policies and implement plans that protect her core interests.
A senior minister invoking what he recently called the South Asian Monroe Doctrine does not augur well for an ancient country at one of the weakest points in her history.
Nor do our Prime Minister’s misleading remarks in the Parliament (of all places) over border violations help heal open wounds that continue to fester.
Still, let’s hope and pray that the upcoming visit will not bring home more goals in our skies, waters and on land, constricting our sovereignty further.







Login to add a comment